Setting: A club for writers of Jesus fan fiction. Modern day
The members of the Jesus fan fiction writing club all write stories of what their idol Jesus might have done. But when the Rapture comes and they find themselves stuck in limbo, each member of the club has to look at their own soul. Who is holding them back from being saved? Cat-killer Camilla? Sexy nightclub singer Judy Garland? Bathroom obsessed Suzanna? Tony, who loves the Backstreet boys too much? Sammy, who sometimes narrates? Or is it the mysterious and wise Leonard Bernstein?